The case involved two brothers, heirs to their mother, who passed away in 2012.
One brother, who died in 2018, was suspected by the surviving brother of having hidden or diverted assets from the estate to the detriment of the other heir.
The aggrieved brother, having discovered suspicious bank transactions in 2014, initiated legal proceedings against his brother’s wife (who had succeeded to the estate), but not until January 2020.
Concealment of an inheritance (recel successoral), as defined by Article 778 of the Civil Code, refers to “any fraudulent or deceitful act knowingly committed by an heir with the intent to disrupt the equal distribution of an estate among co-heirs.”
The penalties are severe: the concealing heir is deemed to have accepted the estate unconditionally and forfeits any claim to the diverted assets. Additionally, they must return all income and profits generated by those assets since the estate was opened.
Until recently, French jurisprudence was divided on the applicable limitation period for actions related to successoral concealment, with some cases using the ten-year period for accepting or renouncing an estate, while others adopted the general five-year limitation.
In this case, the Grenoble Court of Appeal, and subsequently the Supreme Court, ruled that the action was time-barred, as the five-year limitation period had begun in 2014.
In its ruling, the Supreme Court definitively held that “in the absence of specific legislation, the action to sanction successoral concealment, which is a personal action, is subject to the general five-year limitation period provided for in Article 2224 of the Civil Code.”
This period begins on the day the claimant knew or should have known the facts enabling them to take action. In this case, the court found that the plaintiff had been aware of the suspicious transactions since 2014, making his 2020 legal action time expired.
The ruling aligns with the Civil Code’s prescription rules, which established a five-year limitation period for personal and movable actions.
Related Reading:
